Guitar Pick Gift - I'd Pick You Every Time

✈️ Express and international shipping upgrade options are available at checkout.

A stainless steel guitar pick is engraved with "I'd pick you every time" on the front. For an additional $10, we'll also engrave "xo, [name]" or a similar short message of your choice on the back. 


  • Stainless Steel


  • Find sizing info for our jewelry products here.


If you have a question about this or any other product we offer, please reach out. We'd love to help!


Common questions make it to the "Hall of Fame" 🏆 –– a.k.a. our FAQ page


  • Orders over $75 ship free to US addresses.
  • We ship most orders via USPS First Class within 1 business day of ordering. They take 5-7 business days to arrive.
  • Shipping upgrades are available at checkout. Priority Mail arrives in 3-4 business days. Express Mail arrives in 2-3 business days.


  • Due to the custom engraving and personalization of all items, we do not accept returns.  
  • You can always contact us for any reason at to discuss any problems you have.
  • Please inspect your order upon reception and contact us immediately if the item is defective, damaged, or if you receive the wrong item, so that we can evaluate the issue and make it right.

We spread happiness, one gift at a time

We include a gift box or bag with your order.

Your gift is ready to give when you receive your shipment!

Giving uniquely personalized gifts is what we are all about. If you have a completely custom engraving in mind, please let us know how we can help! We have a Design Your Own collection that includes many of our products.

U.S. orders of $75+ ship free with USPS First Class Mail within 1 business day of your order.

Expected delivery time is 5-7 business days after shipping date.

Faster shipping options are available at checkout for an additional charge.

Non-U.S. customers, please review the International Shipping section of our FAQ page.

All our products are handmade by a team of happy women working in a woman-owned business.

We love giving gifts, and we work hard to make your gift-giving and gift-buying experience exceptional.

Buy Custom Guitar Picks from Love, Georgie

Express your feelings with a harmonious twist with Love, Georgie's unique guitar pick, engraved with the phrase "I'd pick you every time". This custom-engraved guitar pick is the perfect fusion of sentimentality and functionality, and is a heartfelt way to tell your loved one you'd pick them every time. When you buy custom guitar picks from Love, Georgie, you're not just purchasing a music accessory; you're creating a timeless keepsake. Made from durable material to withstand the rigors of strumming, each custom guitar pick is expertly engraved with a message that resonates longer than any note. Whether it's a gift for a loved one or a treat for yourself, the phrase "I'd pick you every time" encapsulates a heartfelt promise. It's a melodious reminder of affection for the guitarists who play their feelings into beautiful tunes. Celebrate a special occasion, express love, or inspire a musician in your life with Love, Georgie's custom guitar picks. With every strum, they'll remember the special sentiment behind your gift. Don't just give a gift, instead design a customized guitar pick today!"